When the Doctor Clears You Too Soon
It happens more often than you might think: you’re still in pain, struggling to walk, lift, or focus—and the company doctor suddenly says you’re ready to return to work.
Under South Carolina’s workers’ compensation system, the doctor chosen by your employer or insurance company has major control over your treatment and work status. If that doctor clears you to return, your wage benefits may stop unless you challenge the decision.
That’s why it’s important to act quickly if you disagree with a release or work restriction.
Your Right to a Second Opinion
If you believe the company doctor’s decision doesn’t reflect your true condition, you can request an Independent Medical Examination (IME) from another doctor. This exam provides a second opinion about:
Whether you’ve truly reached maximum medical improvement (MMI)
What restrictions you still need at work
Whether additional treatment or therapy is medically necessary
An experienced workers’ compensation attorney can help you request the IME and present that evidence to the South Carolina Workers’ Compensation Commission if needed.
What Happens If You Go Back Too Soon
Returning before you’re ready can have serious consequences:
You could reinjure yourself and make your condition worse.
Your employer may argue that your ongoing pain isn’t work-related anymore.
You might lose leverage in your claim or settlement discussions.
If your pain or limitations prevent you from doing your job safely, don’t try to push through. Instead, talk to an attorney about how to preserve your benefits and challenge the release properly.
FAQs About Being Cleared Too Soon
What if I can do some work, but not full duty?
Your doctor can recommend light-duty work. If your employer can accommodate those restrictions, you’ll need to cooperate—but the work must truly fit your limitations.
Can I get a new doctor if I disagree with mine?
Yes, but you’ll need approval from the insurance company or the Workers’ Compensation Commission. A lawyer can help make the request and submit the proper paperwork.
What if my employer pressures me to return anyway?
You have a right to follow your doctor’s medical restrictions. If you’re being threatened or disciplined for following those orders, that may violate South Carolina law.
Will my benefits stop while I fight the decision?
Possibly. Temporary benefits may stop once a doctor clears you, but if a second opinion supports your position, your benefits can be reinstated.
Free Consultation for Injured Workers
If your doctor says you’re ready to return to work but you know your body isn’t, don’t ignore your instincts.
At Martin & Martin, P.A., we help injured workers protect their benefits, challenge unfair medical opinions, and make sure they aren’t forced back to work too soon.
📞 Call today for a free consultation to learn your rights and get the help you need before making any decisions.